|
Back to Article Index
Anti-recycling Myths
by JANE BOGNER
SUNDAY, January 28, 2007
Genie Kaggerud (VALCORE President), Peter Friesen (Vallejo
Garbage Service General Manager) and I recently chatted about
the changes in recycling over the eighteen years that we have
worked together. We would have never dreamed of all the interest
or regulations surrounding the items that can now be recycled.
There are still skeptics that are not recycling as
anti-recycling myths continue to re-surface. The Environmental
Defense Fund (EDF) defused the allegations written in a 1996 New
York Times Magazine article entitled Recycling is Garbage. The
following information is relevant today.
Myth: The recycling movement is a product of a false "crisis"
in landfill space."
EDF found that "concentrating on landfill space misses the
point. The greatest environmental benefits of recycling occur in
reducing the damage and pollution that arise when extracting
virgin raw materials and manufacturing new products." Making new
products from recycled aluminum saves 95 percent of energy
needed to make new aluminum. Energy saved by recycling paper is
60 percent and recycling glass is 32 percent.
Myth: Landfill space is cheap and abundant.
There may be cheap land for landfills but they are far away from
urban areas. Fourteen landfills have disappeared around the bay.
The Bay Conservation and Development Commission continue to
regulate the remaining seven; three which will be gone soon.
Potrero Hills near Suisun is one of the remaining four and is
trying to expand its footprint for the garbage it accepts from
communities up to 150 miles away.
Vallejo's garbage goes to the Devlin Road Transfer Station where
it is loaded on trucks and driven to the Keller Canyon landfill
in east Contra Costa County. San Francisco's food waste is
trucked to Jepson Prairie Composting in Vacaville. These huge
garbage trucks share the same highways that we travel on every
day.
Myth: Recycling should pay for itself.
We do not expect landfills to pay for themselves, nor should we
expect this of recycling. In fact, recycling creates more jobs
through collecting and sorting material as well as producing new
goods.
Myth: There are no markets for recycled materials.
Most plastics have limited or non-existent markets, however
aluminum, glass and paper markets remain strong here and over
seas.
Myth: Manufacturers are compelled by law to make costly
changes in their packaging and products.
Lawmakers are slowly making headway by giving manufacturers
reasonable standards for their products. For example, there are
over 50 different types of plastics and only seven are accepted
in the California Redemption Value buy back program. Responsible
companies now design their products to be easily recycled.
Myth: Recycling is a time-consuming burden on the American
public.
Most cities are going to single-stream recycling where paper
goods (newspaper, magazines, cardboard, junk mail) and food
containers (cans and bottles) are placed in one recycling toter.
This mix is then separated at a sorting facility such as the one
that Valeljo Garbage operates on Broadway.
Confusion comes from what materials are recyclable. Most food
packaging such as trays that come with produce, bakery goods or
frozen food, and plastic bags do not have a viable market at
this time. Such packaging is considered trash.
When you receive your new recycling toter this spring, take time
to read the attached label to learn what materials are
recyclable.
Flyway Festival
The 11th Annual Flyway Festival happens February 2 to 4, on Mare
Island in Vallejo. The free Festival celebrates the annual
migration along the Pacific Flyway of hawks, shorebirds, and
monarch butterflies with exhibits, hikes, and birding outings.
The local Sierra Club will again provide compostable plates,
cups and cutlery for the event. The used products will be
composted at VALCORE Recycling. For more information call 707
649-WING or
www.sfbayflywayfestival.com.
VALCORE
Recycling Board Member Jane Bogner's "A Sorted Affair"
is published every other week in the Times-Herald, Community
Outlook Section. For recycling information call her at 645-8258 or visit www.VALCORErecycling.org.
Back to Article Index
|